If you’re unable to work due to a long-term illness or injury, long-term disability (LTD) benefits are meant to ease some of that burden by replacing a portion of your income. But, many Atlantic Canadians are unaware that even though these benefits are long term, they may not last forever.
Depending on the specifics of the policies of your long-term disability benefits, there may be a variety of limits you may be susceptible to. Understanding the different caps on policy benefits can help protect you from unwanted financial hardships. Typical limits you may encounter include:
- Percentage of income cap;
- Maximum benefit duration;
- “Own occupation” limitations;
- Offsets or deductions;
- Mental health or chronic conditions;
- Pre-existing condition exclusions.
The exact wording of your policy, whether it be a group or individual plan, will determine the specifics of your benefit limits. Provincial insurance and employment laws may also influence these benefit limits, as well as the interpretation of language in the policy.
LTD Benefit Limits
As the primary purpose of LTD benefits is to help bridge the financial burdens of being unable to work due to illness or injury, familiarizing yourself with the specifics of possible limits may protect you from experiencing unexpected benefit denial or termination.
Percentage of Income Cap
LTD benefits are meant to replace around 60-70% of your pre-disability earnings, and may have a maximum monthly benefit set by the policy (generally, between $5,000 and $10,000 a month). If your calculated benefit exceeds that maximum, your payments may be limited to the policy amount.
- 60-70% of your pre-disability earnings
- Maximum monthly benefit, if set by the policy (often between $5,000 to $10,000 per month)
Maximum Benefit Duration
Benefit policies may outline that benefits are only to occur during a set period or duration of time, such as 2–, 5–, or 10–years. Familiarizing yourself with the terms in your specific policy can help to determine if a time limitation is in place on your LTD benefits.
Additionally, it’s typical for LTD benefits to end once a worker has reached 65 years of age, or the average retirement age. At that age, a worker may also be eligible for retirement benefits from the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) or Old Age Security (OAS).
- Benefit coverage time limit;
- Worker reaches 65 years of age;
- Recovery of the condition.
“Own Occupation” Limitations
Like with other policy stipulations, the specifics of your LTD policy will outline the exact requirements a worker will need to meet in order to receive benefits.
Many LTD policies initially require that you be unable to perform the main duties of your specific job, as it was prior to your accident.
After that initial period, if you are able to perform another occupation or role that you are reasonably suited to perform based on your education and experience, you may be denied further benefits.
Offsets or Deductions
During the time that you are receiving LTD benefits, additional money received through income or benefit programs may reduce your LTD payments, depending on your policy. Additional money you may be receiving that could lower your payments could include:
- CPP Disability Benefits;
- Workers’ Compensation;
- EI sickness benefits;
- Severance;
- Additional disability benefit plans;
- Income through other sources.
Mental Health or Chronic Conditions
Depending on the exact language used in a plan’s policies, some conditions may only be eligible to receive limited benefits. Examples may include:
- Depression;
- Anxiety;
- Stress-related conditions;
- Chronic pain;
- Fibromyalgia.
For some LTD policies, it may still be possible to collect LTD benefits for particular mental health or chronic conditions, but to a limit of 24 months, unless additional strict medical criteria are proven to be met. But this depends on the wording on the policy.
Pre-Existing Condition Exclusions
For conditions that existed prior to when the policy’s coverage started, it’s typical for some policies to exclude these from possible benefit payments. Though more often seen in group policies, this may be the case in individual LTD benefit policies as well.
My LTD Benefits Have Been Capped – Now What?
Dealing with a denial, termination, reaching a monthly maximum, or an additional income offset – facing any cap or limitation on your LTD can be jarring to your life. Due to the nature of LTD benefits, workers relying on these benefits may not have the luxury of being able to wait for a denial appeal to be processed or for additional benefit funds to become available. In these challenging instances, it may be advisable for impacted individuals to speak with legal counsel, and potentially seek out damages.
Can I Challenge a Denial or Limit?
To challenge a denial, limit, or other discrepancies with your LTD benefits, filing an internal appeal directly with the insurance company may be the quickest course of action. Especially in cases where a worker was denied for:
- Insufficient medical evidence;
- Incomplete documentation;
- Missing information
In some instances, a denial could be overturned just through providing additional details like medical records, specialist reports, or further clarification regarding issues specific to your unique situation. Providing these additional details may be sufficient to have the insurer reconsider and overturn a denial decision. However, a successful appeal is not guaranteed.
Internal appeals can take months to run their natural course, and to come to completion. For an individual receiving LTD benefits for an injury or illness that’s preventing them from work, this can mean they are left unable to earn income, waiting for an appeal decision, and low on funds. This lengthy process can create significant financial hardships for those waiting for a determination to be made.
After a lengthy review, it’s also possible that the insurer may maintain their original decision to deny or limit, regardless of additional information. Legal counsel may recommend pursuing a claim against this insurer for a wrongful denial. It is also important to note that an internal appeal may not extend the deadline to start a court claim.
Compensation?
- Previously denied benefit payments;
- Past and future benefits owed;
- Legal costs, where recoverable;
- Damages for mental distress, where established;
- Punitive damages in exceptional cases of bad faith.
Times to Challenge a Policy Cap
Whether you should challenge a denial or cap to your LTD benefits can depend on a number of factors. Policy working, specifics for the limitation, or evidence available can all impact the final decision for a benefit payment. Common situations that you could find success in challenging your LTD benefit cap may include:
Ambiguous Wording
Some policies can be confusing, poorly written, or overall vague in their language. If a dispute reaches court, ambiguity that remains after the usual routes of interpretation may be resolved in favour of the insured person, versus in favour of the party that drafted the contract.
Improper “Mental Health” Limitations
Some policies impose 24 month limitations for certain mental health conditions. Their application can be more complex where a person also has:
- Physical injuries or conditions;
- Chronic pain;
- Neurological disorders;
- Overlapping medical conditions.
Medical documentation and specialist evidence may help explain how overlapping conditions affect the person’s ability to work.
The “Any Occupation” Test
After the “own occupation” period of benefits has concluded, insurers may attempt to terminate benefits by claiming that the individual can do “any occupation.” These decisions may be challenged based on:
- Unrealistic proposed work;
- Lacking transferable skills;
- The proposed work not being reasonably comparable.
Failure to Investigate Evidence
A denial may be challenged if the insurer fails to fairly consider the relevant evidence available, such as by:
- Overlooking doctors’ notes or medical records;
- Cherry-picking evidence;
- Relying on unsupported assumptions.
Discrimination or Human Rights Infringements
In some cases, a denial or limitation can be challenged through human rights principles, depending on the specific situation and the exact structure and wording within a benefit plan.
Bad Faith
In Canada, if an insurer has acted in bad faith, courts can award additional damages to the impacted person(s) where claims were handled inappropriately.
Before deciding to challenge a cap, be sure to:
- Review your specific policy;
- Maintain copies of all denial or termination letters;
- Maintain copies of all medical documentation;
- Review employment or collective agreement documentation;
- Compile all written correspondence with the insurer.
Long-term disability benefits are largely determined by the specific wording outlined in an insurance policy, and other related benefit documents. While some denied claims or benefit limitations can be successfully challenged, either through appeals or through a court decision, insurers may still uphold their original decisions in certain cases.
Understanding the precise terms, conditions, and exclusions within your policy can help protect your rights and reduce the risk of future financial hardships or difficulties due to an unexpected LTD benefits cap. Speaking with an experienced long-term disability lawyer may help you to better understand your options, as well as provide strength through experience to a potential claim.



