After a car accident, many people assume the police report will decide who was at fault.

That is not always true.

A police report can be important, such as when providing context to insurance companies and lawyers, but it is not necessarily the final word on who is responsible. Police officers usually arrive after the crash and must piece together what happened using driver statements, witness accounts, physical evidence at the scene, and their own observations.

Sometimes mistakes happen.

A report may contain wrong information, leave out important details or miss key witnesses. In some cases, the officer’s understanding of the crash may not match what actually happened.

If you have read information in a police collision report and believe something is wrong, there may still be ways to address the issue and provide evidence supporting your version of events. Accident claims are decided using all available evidence, not just police reports.

In Nova Scotia, it is also important to distinguish between a police report, an insurer’s determination of fault, and a court’s determination of legal responsibility. They are not necessarily the same thing. For insured automobile loss or damage, insurers must determine fault in accordance with Nova Scotia’s Automobile Insurance Fault Determination Regulations.

Understanding how police reports fit into the process can help you decide what to do next.

What Is a Police Accident Report?

A police accident report is a document prepared in connection with a motor vehicle crash.

Depending on the circumstances of the incident and the type of record involved, the report may include:

  • Driver information;
  • Vehicle information;
  • Insurance details;
  • Witness statements or contact information;
  • A diagram of the crash;
  • Road and weather conditions;
  • Officer observations;
  • Statements from the drivers involved;
  • Traffic tickets or charges; and
  • An opinion about fault or apparent contributing factors.

Police reports are often reviewed by:

  • Insurance companies;
  • Lawyers;
  • Courts; and
  • Crash experts.

However, police officers often arrive after the collision has already happened. In those cases, the officer did not personally see the incident. Instead, police may rely on statements from drivers, witness accounts, vehicle damage, road conditions or other evidence found at the scene. 

For that reason, information recorded by police should not automatically be treated as a final determination of what exactly went wrong or who was at fault. In fact, in some cases, there may be significant restrictions on their use at trial.

Are Police Reports Always Accurate?

No. Police reports can contain mistakes. Even experienced officers may receive incomplete information or hear different versions of what happened. 

Common issues may include:

  • Incorrect driver statements;
  • Missing witness information;
  • Errors in diagrams;
  • Wrong dates or times;
  • Vehicle identification mistakes;
  • Confusion about lane positions;
  • Missing road conditions; and
  • Missing injury information or incorrect assumptions about fault.

Most mistakes are not intentional. Car accidents happen quickly. Drivers may be injured, upset, or confused, and witnesses may remember events differently. As a result, important details can sometimes be missed.

Does a Police Report Automatically Determine Fault?

No. A police report is only one piece of evidence. Insurance companies, lawyers, and courts may also look at:

  • Photographs;
  • Dashcam footage;
  • Security video;
  • Vehicle damage;
  • Witness statements;
  • Medical records;
  • Vehicle data; and
  • Expert opinions.

Furthermore, in Nova Scotia, insurance fault determination is separate from being found liable for an injury claim at civil court. For insured automobile loss or damage, Nova Scotia insurers are required to determine an insured’s degree of fault according to the Automobile Insurance Fault Determination Regulations.

A civil personal injury claim is different. Legal responsibility may depend on the applicable law and the admissible evidence concerning how the collision occurred.

A police report may affect how an insurance company initially understands the accident, but it does not automatically determine the ultimate result. Even if the report appears to work against you, other evidence may support your version of events.

Why Police Reports Sometimes Get Things Wrong 

There can be several reasons why information in a report may not accurately reflect what happened.

Police Usually Arrive After the Crash

Most officers investigate the scene after the collision. They must piece together events using the information available at the time. If that information is incomplete or conflicting, errors can occur.

Drivers May Be Injured or Distressed

After a crash, people are often shaken, confused, or in pain. Someone may accidentally provide incomplete or incorrect information without realizing.

Witnesses Can Be Mistaken

Witnesses can be helpful, but they are not always right. A witness may have seen only part of the crash, had a poor view or misunderstood what happened.

Important Evidence May Be Missing Initially

Some evidence may not become available until later. This can include dashcam footage, surveillance video, vehicle data, photographs from other people at the scene, or additional witness statements. 

A report completed shortly after a crash may not reflect all of evidence available to be discovered.

What Happens if the Police Report Is Wrong?

Incorrect information in a police report can create complications. It may affect the way an insurance adjuster initially evaluates the collision or the way the parties approach an injury or property damage claim

If the report wrongly blames you for the crash, the insurance company may question your version of events. It may also challenge fault or reduce the amount it is willing to pay. 

However, an incorrect report does not determine the outcome of your case or mean your claim cannot proceed. For an injury claim, other evidence may help establish what happened and whether one or more parties were negligent.

Can You Correct a Police Report?

Sometimes, depending on the nature of the error and the procedures of the police agency involved.

If you discover an objective factual error, such as an incorrect name, vehicle detail, date, location, or insurance information, you can contact the investigating police agency and ask about correcting or supplementing the information

Changing an officer’s observations or conclusions may be more difficult, especially about fault or the circumstances contributing to the accident. A police department is not necessarily required to change a report simply because one of the drivers disagrees with what the officer recorded.

If significant information was omitted, you may be able to ask whether an additional statement or supporting evidence can be provided. Whether the original report will actually be amended depends on the circumstances and the police agency’s procedures.

Even if the initial report itself is not changed, that new evidence may still help during an insurance claim or lawsuit.

Evidence That Can Help

Strong independent evidence is often the best way to challenge mistakes in a police report. Helpful evidence may include:

Photographs

Photos taken at the scene may show vehicle damage, road markings, traffic signs, weather conditions, debris, skid marks, visibility, and the position of the vehicles. These details can help explain how the crash happened.

Dashcam Footage

Dashcam footage can be some of the strongest evidence in a disputed accident claim because it may show the movement of the vehicles immediately before the collision. This may contradict the key inaccurate witness statements or information in a police report. 

Some systems automatically overwrite old recordings, so it is important to save the relevant footage as soon as possible.

Security Video

Nearby businesses, homes, or traffic cameras may have recorded the collision. Video footage can sometimes provide a clear picture of what happened and help resolve disagreements about fault.

Similarly to dashcam footage, surveillance camera video recordings are often kept for only a limited period, so identifying and preserving potential footage quickly can be important.

Witness Statements 

Independent witnesses can be especially helpful when both sides disagree about what happened, as they have no personal interest in the outcome of the claim.

A witness may be able to describe the colour of a traffic light, the location or movement of a vehicle, whether a vehicle changed lanes, whether a driver appeared distracted, or what they observed immediately before the collision.

Witnesses are not always perfect in their recollection, but their observations can help support or contradict other evidence.

Crash Experts

In serious cases or complicated cases, an accident-reconstruction or other qualified expert may be asked to review the evidence. 

Depending on the circumstances, an expert may consider vehicle damage, impact locations, roadway evidence, vehicle data, measurements, photographs, and other information when forming an opinion about how the collision occurred.

Medical Records

Medical records may also help. In some cases, injury patterns support one version of events over another. Medical records can also help show the seriousness of the injuries.

Should You Contact the Insurance Company if the Report is Wrong?

You should be careful when discussing disputed fault with the other driver’s insurance company. An insurance adjuster may ask you to provide a statement about how the collision happened, your injuries, or other details of the claim. 

The adjusters may record these statements and use them against you later or look for inconsistencies in your evidence. What you say may affect how the insurer evaluates fault and your claim. If your account later differs from an earlier statement, those inconsistencies may also become important if the dispute leads to litigation.

For that reason, avoid guessing about speeds, distances, fault, or details you do not clearly remember. If you are unsure about something, it is better to say that you do not know or do not remember than to speculate.

Before giving detailed recorded statements to the other driver’s insurer, you may benefit from speaking with a lawyer, particularly if you were seriously injured, fault is disputed, the police information contains significant errors, multiple vehicles were involved, or litigation may be possible.

This is different from communicating with your own insurer. Your automobile insurance policy may require you to promptly report the accident and cooperate with your insurer in relation to the claim.

What if the Other Driver Lied to Police?

Unfortunately, this does happen. Some drivers try to shift blame after an accident. Others leave out important details or provide information that is not accurate. If an officer relied on incorrect information, the report may not reflect what really happened.

That is one reason why independent evidence can be so important. Dashcam footage, witness statements, photographs, and expert analysis may help expose inconsistencies and provide a clearer picture of what occurred.

Can a Lawyer Help Challenge an Incorrect Police Report?

Yes. A lawyer may be able to help by:

  • Reviewing available police records and collision information
  • Reviewing witness statements;
  • Gathering additional evidence;
  • Preserving video footage;
  • Working with experts;
  • Communicating with insurers; and 
  • Challenging disputed fault claims.

In serious injury cases, legal help may be especially valuable because fault disputes can have a major impact on the amount of money that may be recovered.

Even if a police report appears to work against you, further investigation may reveal evidence that supports your version of events.

What if the Police Report Says You Were at Fault?

A police report that blames you for a collision does not automatically end your injury claim or conclusively determine civil liability.

The report is only one piece of evidence. Insurance companies, lawyers, and courts generally look at all available evidence before reaching their own conclusions about who was responsible.

In some accidents, more than one driver may share responsibility. For example, one driver may have been speeding while another failed to yield, with both actions contributing to the collision.

As additional evidence becomes available, it may also become apparent that important details were missing or misunderstood when the original police information was recorded.

How Long Do You Have to Dispute an Accident Claim?

Different time limits may apply to insurance claims and lawsuits. 

In Nova Scotia, many motor vehicle injury claims are affected by the Limitation of Actions Act, which establishes a basic limitation period based on when the claim is discovered. You should not assume, however, that every accident-related deadline is the same. Automobile insurance policies can contain much shorter notice and proof-of-claim requirements.

Waiting too long may create problems such as lost evidence, unavailable witnesses, deleted surveillance footage, and weakened recollections. For these reasons, it is often important to act quickly if a police report contains major inaccuracies. 

How Can You Protect Yourself After a Car Accident?

While not every mistake can be prevented, there are several steps that may help protect your rights and preserve important evidence after a crash.

Take Photos Immediately

If it is safe to do so, take photos of vehicle damage, the roadway, traffic signs, road conditions, skid marks, and visible injuries. Photos taken shortly after a collision can become valuable evidence later.

Gather Witness Information 

If witnesses are present, try to get their names, phone numbers, and email addresses. Witnesses may leave before police arrive, making them harder to contact later.

Avoid Guessing About Fault 

After a crash, people are often upset, injured, or confused. Try not to guess about speeds, distances, or fault. If you do not know the answer to a question, it is usually better to say so than to speculate.

Seek Medical Attention

If you are injured or experiencing symptoms, seek appropriate medical attention. Prompt medical care is important for both your health and your claim. Medical records can help document your symptoms, diagnosis, treatment, and the timeline of your injuries.

Preserve Evidence 

Keep copies of photos, repair estimates, medical records, receipts, and insurance communications. The more information you keep, the easier it may be to support your claim later.

Speak With a Lawyer Early

In cases involving serious injuries or disagreements about fault, early legal advice may help protect your rights. A lawyer may also help preserve evidence before it is lost.

Can Police Reports Be Used in Court?

Yes. Police reports can sometimes be used as evidence in court.

However, courts do not rely only on the report when deciding a case. Instead, they consider all available evidence. 

For that reason, a report that contains mistakes does not automatically decide the outcome of a case. Courts may give different weight to different parts of a police report. Some observations may be more helpful than others depending on the facts of the case.

How We Can Help

A police report that gets the facts wrong can complicate an insurance claim and make it harder to recover compensation, particularly when responsibility for a collision is disputed. However, an inaccurate report does not have to be the end of the story. Other evidence may help show what really happened and correct mistakes in the report.

Our team can request and review available collision information, investigate the circumstances of the crash, gather additional evidence, take steps to preserve relevant video footage, work with qualified experts when appropriate, and address disputed allegations of fault. 

The sooner you seek advice, the easier it may be to gather and preserve important evidence.

If you were injured in a collision and believe the police report does not accurately reflect what happened. Contact NOVA Injury Law for a free consultation to learn more about your rights and discuss your situation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.